Everyday Driver Fiesta ST vs. Golf GTI at track

Discussion in 'Fiesta ST News and Reviews' started by meFiSTo, Jul 26, 2014.

  1. meFiSTo

    meFiSTo Active Member

    I was out of town when this was posted to YouTube and found it the other day. I have not been able to find it here, so I'll share it:



    If it has already been posted, my apologies.

    Too bad we don't get the Polo GTi (or Polo for that matter) for a more apples to apples comparison. But still, the Fiesta ST appears to come out on top from the reviewers' POV over the Golf GTi.

    Some interesting back and forth down in the comments near the top. To tell the truth, I usually dread reading comments in most online postings/articles. People get all worked up and irrational (from politics to sports to cars). This thing wasn't too bad.
     
  2. Register or Sign in

    Advertisement Sponsor

     
  3. djdennehy

    djdennehy Active Member

    Cannot wait for next week (going to Octane Academy) to be able to get some genuine seat time in a FiST on the track (even better when it isn't your own). Glad you added this video, I hadn't seen it. A friend who has a MK6 GTI and I traded keys and we both felt similarly about the current GTI versus the FiST, more torque but not as good handling.
     
  4. ghostwhite

    ghostwhite Active Member

    The fiesta is better on track for sure. I'm just super jealous that a mk7 gti makes 316 hp stage 1. 316hp 368ftlbs crank is insane! Plus 87 hp and 115 ftlbs
     
  5. Teezlr

    Teezlr Member

    Livernois tune is making something close at the crank. I think it was +78 wheel torque
     
  6. ghostwhite

    ghostwhite Active Member

    Livernoise sage 1 for fiesta is +20hp and 70ftlbs at the crank
     
    Teezlr likes this.
  7. Teezlr

    Teezlr Member

    Yeah I see 73 crank torque and 20 hp, not much compared to the gti, also a 2.0 with a larger turbo so makes sense
     
  8. ghostwhite

    ghostwhite Active Member

    Yeah it's also making stage 3 focus st numbers with just a tune. They seem like the strongest 2.0 turbo out with a small ko3 out now. Interested to see what they put down with a downpipe and intercooler
     
    Teezlr likes this.
  9. Teezlr

    Teezlr Member

    Dude... just looked at APR's stage 1 tune claiming a full second in the 1/4 mile and 13 mph faster.... 13 mph from a tune! Crazy haha
     
  10. ghostwhite

    ghostwhite Active Member

    Yeah I know it's insane
     
  11. sourskittle

    sourskittle Member

    In my experience, with lots of VW friends, the APR stuff is nice and drives great, but every single time EVER they goto the track, they leave disappointed by about 1.5sec. APR has built some amazing machines, but I think they mis-lead people on what to expect.

    In the flipside, that 2.0L new GTi motor seems to be an animal. But just like the focus ST, they can make all the power in the world,
    But...
    THEY CAN NOT LOSE 500lbs.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  12. Teezlr

    Teezlr Member

    Yeah, still doesn't make it as fun to drive I'm sure... same car more powa
     
  13. razorlab

    razorlab Active Member

    I agree with you about lightweight cars but the MK7 GTI weighs 3030lbs, so a good amount lighter than the current 3200lb Focus ST.
     
  14. sourskittle

    sourskittle Member

    Same difference. I'd personally like to see a GTi spec'd out the way people actualy will buy them, on a real scale.

    Point is... We can make a lot more power with relative ease. They can not lose 100's of lbs with relative ease


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  15. razorlab

    razorlab Active Member

    They are lighter than the MK6's and that weight is with normal spec that most of the % of GTI buyers spec out.

    My point was the FiST is not 500lbs lighter than a GTI.
     
  16. sourskittle

    sourskittle Member

    Pretty sure it was motortrend that weighed one. I don't care enough to look it up, but they said they were "slightly disappointed in how much weight it DID NOT lose vs the last model they tested".

    I haven't put one on the scale, but the point is still valid. We can make basically the same power with relative ease, while the can not lose 100's of pounds with relative ease .


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  17. razorlab

    razorlab Active Member

    Splitting hairs at this point but no, we cannot make +80whp/+100wtq from a simple flash on pump gas with no other modifications. The FiST won't even do half that.
     
  18. sourskittle

    sourskittle Member

    But we can do a simple turbo swap and pro tune and make 80whp. Car would drive, ride, turn, mpg the same with the same amount of comfort. They can make that power, but to get to our weight , they have to lose everything that makes a $32k GTi.... $32k, lol.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  19. razorlab

    razorlab Active Member

    Oh c'mon now you are just bending facts to try and make your point.

    A common GTI is not $32k.

    MSRP starts at $25k and ends at $32k. Nobody pays MSRP. Hardly anybody gets the $32k MSRP Autobahn model. The base GTI is the top seller and it is $25k MSRP.

    "But we can do a simple turbo swap and pro tune and make 80whp." Yea ok. Simple. Sure.
     
    ghostwhite likes this.
  20. sourskittle

    sourskittle Member

    I've taken the turbo off a fist... Have you? It actually is simple... Honestly.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  21. ghostwhite

    ghostwhite Active Member

    No such thing a simple turbo swap. Especially with all the maintenance. Stock turbo plus tune is simple
     

Share This Page